
I just don’t get it.
For years now, audio/video products have been getting better and better (valve-lovers [including me] may disagree on some level, but that’s a discussion for another day!).
Huge R&D budgets have been spent on getting higher quality sound and better pictures in front of consumers with large jumps in technology to the point that old proven formats are becoming out of date now.
So what has gone wrong in the last few years?
In many ways things have improved: CDs and DVDs have bought digital quality to the home. Blu-ray and HD-DVD are improving on that even more.
But we also seem to often be going backwards and sacrificing something important: quality. At what cost does convenience come?
Some examples:
1) iPods. Dont get me wrong, iPods serve a purpose as an effective replacement for the old Sony Walkman and are great on the move. They hold a zillion songs which is a lot better than a tape or CD. They have a good display and interface. But the sound quality sucks. Its fine for when you are on the move, but who in their right mind would use an iPod for serious sound?
Well it appears some people are, as you can see with $400 cables to connect your iPod to your stereo. Its just mad. Now I am a bit of an audiophile so fully understand that good cables can make a big difference (I admit to having a fair assortment of good cables I then treated with liquid nitrogen…), but the simple saying “garbage in, garbage out” applies with your iPod feeding a good stereo. It doesn’t matter how good your amp is, the music will not sound nearly as good as music from a half decent source, even if that music is in the same AAC or MP3 format. Some may say its a matter of reducing signal loss, but when you start with crap, trust me, a percentage point or two extra signal loss is not relevant. And certainly not worth buying $400 cables. Even if you have a lot of cash.
So what is their logic? Is the convenience of having a small music source (ironically, most likely connected to a large 45 pound amp and two 20 pound speakers!) worth the sacrifice of sound quality on your good stereo and with your good cables? Nope. Its just dumb, and I cant imagine anyone who would buy those cables would actually be an audiophile as their good stereo would not be running off an iPod in the first place. Period.
2) LCD TV’s: I was at a local store checking out some blu-ray and an AppleTV, which happened to be connected to a top of the line 52″ LCD TV. Cool, a TV that is thin…better profile than a CRT. But the picture quality? Absolute rubbish. Even a not very visually astute friend of mine commented on it. Large screen. Thin TV. Poor quality. The colors – muddy. It looked like a 128 colour palette and a face looked appalling with none of the subtleties of colour and detail that denote a good picture. Motion isn’t very good either. Just doesn’t look right. And lines were jagged, looking like it needed a healthy dose of 16x anti-aliasing like used in video games to improve straight lines from the dreaded jaggies.
And it cost a fortune – $6100.
Who on earth would buy it? Not only does it sacrifice quality for large picture size and a thin profile, but the most amazing thing is that there is another viable alternative that has all the benefits and a much lower cost, and a much better picture quality if you buy the right one: plasma TVs! There is just no excuse for people buying rubbish when probably about 3m away is the same concept with great picture for 1/3 of the price. Plasma unlike LCD has come of age (finally!). I am sure LCDs will eventually too, but for now, no way. The only place I would buy one for was if I needed a small TV on a cramped office desk.
So where does it end? At this rate in another 5 years we will all have 80″ monochrome monitors with a 1Hz refresh rate and the sound will be from a seriously cool little device, but with the quality of a wax recording.
Bring back quality I say. Enough sacrificing quality for convenience or simply to allow a company to compete in a market segment that simply offers stupid people more stupid choices.